The Place for Jersey City News
Log In / Register
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
Jersey City Times
  • News
  • Food and Fun
    • Food And Drink
    • Performing Arts
    • Visual Arts
    • Other Fun Stuff
  • Education
  • Business
  • Neighborhoods
    • Downtown
      • News
      • Guide
    • Heights
      • News
      • Guide
    • Journal Square
      • News
      • Guide
    • Bergen Lafayette
      • News
      • Guide
    • Greenville
      • News
      • Guide
    • Westside
      • News
      • Guide
  • Opinion
  • Columns
    • Eye Level
    • Mamarama
  • Obituaries
  • Event Calendar
  • Support our Mission
  • Search
  • Menu Menu
Consultant to City: Pony Up For Tree Maintenance

Consultant to City: Pony Up For Tree Maintenance

Elizabeth Morrill
April 13, 2022/in header, Narrate, News
by Elizabeth Morrill

In its October 2021 report commissioned by the city of Jersey City, Davey Resource Group, a multinational tree care consulting company, recommends that, for the next five years, Jersey City nearly double its spending on trees and, in a departure from the city’s longstanding practice, prioritize all forms of tree maintenance over tree planting.

The report, which is based on a “significant but partial” inventory of the city’s trees conducted from 2018 to 2021, uses economic language to state its case.

“Supporting and funding the proactive maintenance of the public tree resource is a sound long-term investment that will reduce tree management costs over time,” Davey said.

Davey analyzed three aspects of Jersey City’s tree canopy and noted several bright spots.

Of approximately 13,000 trees inventoried, 83 percent are in “fair” or better condition. The age distribution of the city’s trees is “starting to trend toward ideal.” And in 2020, 24 percent of the city’s tree budget was effectively reimbursed by the trees by virtue of the many environmental benefits that trees provide, according to the report.

But the report revealed real threats to the city’s tree canopy. Forty-eight percent of the city’s trees are in only “fair” condition, and 17 percent are “fair/poor.”

Most startling to some advocates is the divergence between Jersey City’s forestry budget — and the priorities it reflects — and those Davey recommends.

From 2015 to 2020, the city spent an average of $361,000 per year (exclusive of salaries) on trees and had no budget line specifically for tree maintenance, according to information obtained via an OPRA (Open Public Records Act) request.

Davey advises the city spend $800,000 (on average) annually for the next five years, most of which should be allocated toward maintenance, not planting.

“Planting new trees is important for increasing population size and urban canopy but cannot wait until higher priority maintenance is complete or at least in progress,” the report reads.

So relatively unimportant does Davey consider planting for the immediate protection of the city’s tree canopy that in a graphic that shows how the city should prioritize nine different forestry management activities, the planting of new trees is dead last.

Jersey City's 2018 Forestry Standards

Jersey City’s 2018 Forestry Standards

Even for the layperson, it isn’t hard to find evidence of poor tree maintenance. On just one block Downtown at Christopher Columbus Drive and Barrow Street, six trees are being “strangled” by metal grates specifically banned by Jersey City’s own 2018 Forestry Standards.

While Davey’s recommendations represent a seismic shift in priorities for the city, they should not come as news to City Hall.

In 2010 the city designated only two activities as “high priority” in its Community Forestry Management Plan: pruning and updating the city’s shade tree inventory; and the city’s 2015 CFMP further deemed regular, systematic pruning (ideally every tree every ten years) “one of the four highest priority tasks” (though writing candidly, the report’s authors then went on to characterize this goal, which Davey describes as the bare minimum a pruning cycle the city should implement, as “not achievable”).

But forestry has been a continuing problem area for Jersey City. The Jersey City Times reported on the 2018 culling of 84 mature London Plane trees from the West Side neighborhood of Society Hill. During the period between 2014 to 2019 Jersey City planted 212 trees per year on average as opposed to the 700–1,000 recommended by the 2015 plan, and when taking tree removals into account, lost 104 trees on average during this time period.

It is precisely this disconnect between the city’s words and its deeds that led Ryan Metz, a former forester for Jersey City, to resign in 2018.

“It was very clear to me that Jersey City had no political will whatsoever to implement any kind of forestry program,” Metz told the Jersey City Times in 2020 in an interview on the city’s shrinking tree canopy.

Tree "strangled" by banned metal grate

Tree on Christopher Columbus Drive “strangled” by banned metal grate

More recently, a tree planting program on Central Avenue was botched.

Whether or not the will has increased to implement a forestry program, including the city’s hiring at least two foresters, is open to debate. On the one hand, the city’s Shade Tree Committee will soon issue revised Forestry Standards that expand upon definitions in the manual, update tree selection criteria and clarify tree planting protocols.

On the other hand, left largely untouched in this process will be the section dealing with maintenance, which currently sets forth care standards for a tree’s first two years after planting but says nothing about what these standards should be—nor who has responsibility for them—after a tree turns two.

In this context, in January the committee’s chairwoman, Councilwoman Mira Prinz-Arey, penned a letter on behalf of the committee to the mayor and her colleagues on the council recommending the city “allocate a yearly tree maintenance budget” and “fully fund and staff the forestry department”—among five other things at this “critical point” in the city’s stewardship of its tree canopy.

Tags: Jersey City Environment and Sustainability
Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on WhatsApp
  • Share on Pinterest
  • Share on LinkedIn
You might also like
38 Wayne Street Jersey City New Parking Rules Could Bring Dirtier Streets, Flooding and Water Pollution
Damaged tree trunk Critics Charge City Botched Huge Central Avenue Tree Planting
Tree maintenance Shade Tree Committee Caught off Guard by Tonight’s Forestry Vote
Turnpike Extension Project Activists Say ‘No!’ to Pike Extension Impacting JC
Turnpike Extension Holland Tunnel Entrance Group to Host Virtual Workshop Tonight on “Toxic” Turnpike Extension
Jersey City, US
1:16 pm, July 5, 2022
86°F
clear sky
Wind: 18 mph
Pressure: 1015 mb

Latest Articles

Christopher Columbus Drive Jersey City
July 04, 2022 /

Downtown Streets Gridlocked by Fireworks Traffic

327 Ege Ave Jersey City
July 04, 2022 /

Report: Fireworks Suspected in West Side House Fire

Forget the Whale
July 02, 2022 /

Rogue Waves July: Six Concert Picks in Jersey City

Raisa Nosova "Uprooted"
July 01, 2022 /

Muralist Raisa Nosova Raises a Distress call for Ukraine

Dickinson High School Jersey City 16x9
July 01, 2022 /

Former Dickinson High School Teacher Pleads Guilty to Sexual Assault

CONTACT US

    ADS/INFO

    For information on advertising opportunities, please contact - ads@jcitytimes.com

    For information on writing opportunities, please contact - info@jcitytimes.com

    Download our media kit here

    ABOUT US

    About Jersey City Times

    Contact Jersey City Times

    Social

    Archives

    • July 2022
    • June 2022
    • May 2022
    • April 2022
    • March 2022
    • February 2022
    • January 2022
    • December 2021
    • November 2021
    • October 2021
    • September 2021
    • August 2021
    • July 2021
    • June 2021
    • May 2021
    • April 2021
    • March 2021
    • February 2021
    • January 2021
    • December 2020
    • November 2020
    • October 2020
    • September 2020
    • August 2020
    • July 2020
    • June 2020
    • May 2020
    • April 2020
    • March 2020
    • February 2020
    • January 2020
    • December 2019
    • November 2019
    • October 2019
    Copyright © 2020 JCityTimes.com. All Rights Reserved - powered by Enfold WordPress Theme
    Income Tax for Schools and Cannabis Overdoses Discussed by Council Jersey City City Hall Crime Scene Tape Man Shot in Bergen-Lafayette
    Scroll to top